and it isn’t superman. I am somewhat skeptical about faith the Israeli’s are putting in air power in their current campaign against Hezbollah in Lebanon – I think they will find they need boots on the ground the achieve their goals
It appears that the Israelis have spent the past 6 years since they pulled out of south Lebanon gathering intel on Hezbollah weapon stockpiles, firing points and command structures in the area. Now they believe that they can destroy most if not all of those rockets using only airpower. There is some evidence of minimal use of ground troops, but so far these look like limited incursions close to the border – more like patrols than anything else.
It seems, therefore, that the Israeli’s have bought into one of the great myths of twentieth century warfare – that air power is a ‘magic bullet’ which can win wars on its own. While air superiority is essential for victory in modern war, it has never ‘won’ a war on its own. The Israeli Air Force has an outstanding track record. Even if most of the opposition it faced was second rate for much of the period since 1948, it performed brilliantly. Control of the air in the major wars was a key contributor to the overall Israeli victories in ’67 and ’73. Those victories were in regular wars, against conventional armies, and air power was only a contributor to an overall effort.
Now it seems that they have decided that they can achieve a ‘mission kill’ against Hezbollah using only air power. I think this will fail, for many reasons. Notwithstanding the striking power of modern precision-guided munitions, they are not always accurate and even when they are, they do not always destroy their targets – Hezbollah will certainly salvage some weapons from ‘destroyed’ bunkers. Additionally, no matter how good Israeli intelligence is, they will miss some stockpiles entirely. Even with ground troops to follow-up, they will not get all the Hezbollah weapons, and Northern Israel will continue to be vulnerable to rocket attacks.
It is also obvious that as long as their air campaign goes on, there will be civilian casualties. Every dead Lebanese civilian costs Israel support in the west (although one wonders if they care about world public opinion) and also breeds resentement in Lebanon that is the best recruiting sargent that Hezbollah could wish for.
It is hard to see how the IDF thought this would work, but they do seem to have a real problem coming up with any workable strategy for Lebanon.
Leave a Reply