{"id":8,"date":"2018-10-05T11:11:36","date_gmt":"2018-10-05T11:11:36","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/?page_id=8"},"modified":"2018-10-15T13:20:46","modified_gmt":"2018-10-15T13:20:46","slug":"testing-hypothesis","status":"publish","type":"page","link":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/testing-hypothesis\/","title":{"rendered":"Testing Hypothesis"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>1. Introduction<br \/>\nEducational technology plays an important role in developing and<br \/>\nsupporting instructional activities that promote learning and facilitate<br \/>\nstudents&#8217; engagement in a learning process. Social annotation (SA) tools are an emerging educational technology that has been<br \/>\ndrawing more of educators&#8217; attention over the last several years. SA<br \/>\ntechnology is an online social bookmarking tool that allows annotating<br \/>\n(adding comments, highlights, sticky notes, etc.) of an electronic<br \/>\nresource and supports easy online information sharing. SA technology<br \/>\noffers knowledge sharing solutions and a social platform for interactions<br \/>\nand discussions.<br \/>\nSA tools provide a means for users to modify or attach any type of<br \/>\ncontent to any electronic resource (usually a text) where users can interact.<br \/>\nSocial annotation tools enable users to collaboratively underline,<br \/>\nhighlight, and annotate an electronic text, in addition to<br \/>\nproviding a mechanism to write additional comments on the margins<br \/>\nof the electronic document (Huang, Huang, &amp; Hsieh, 2008; Kawase,<br \/>\nHerder, &amp; Nejdl, 2009). The embedded annotations such as tags, comments,<br \/>\nand highlights can be shared with other users at a time later<br \/>\non. A SA technology is a multi-purpose system that facilitates adding,<br \/>\nediting, and modifying information in an electronic resource without<br \/>\nchanging the resource itself. It also allows users to share their annotations<br \/>\nand web resources with friends or group\/project members and<br \/>\ndiscuss the content of a certain resource, which fosters new level of<br \/>\nknowledge through aggregating information from many users. The<br \/>\nannotations can be thought of as an addition layer of information on<br \/>\ntop of the existing resource that can be shared with other users<br \/>\nusing the same SA system.<br \/>\nSA tools are sometimes confused with Text Annotation tools such<br \/>\nas MS Word, Adobe PDF, Google Docs. Similar to SA tools, it is possible<br \/>\nto make comments and highlight electronic text in MS Word or<br \/>\nAdobe PDF, for example. However, Text Annotation tools are not considered<br \/>\nSA technology, since they do not provide an online social platform<br \/>\nfor information sharing. A user has to share manually an MS<br \/>\nWord or Adobe PDF annotated document via email or other communication<br \/>\nmethods. Other tools provide an online social platform for information<br \/>\nsharing but lack some of the SA technology characteristics.<br \/>\nFor example, Google Docs provides an online social support platform<br \/>\nbut does not allow annotating of newly uploaded electronic materials\/<br \/>\ndocuments created via other tools.<br \/>\nIn order to facilitate discussion of educational uses of the SA technology,<br \/>\nthe following SA features have been identified. First, SA technology<br \/>\nallows users to make written annotations such as notes or<br \/>\ncomments. Annotating is implemented by creating and attaching<br \/>\ncomments to specific sentences or areas within an electronic resource.<br \/>\nSecond, within a SA system a user can highlight any part of<br \/>\nelectronic text using either different colors or various types of notations<br \/>\nand marks including underlining, circling, or boxing selected<br \/>\npassages within the text. Third, SA technology provides an online<br \/>\nplatform for social collaboration. It enables creating private groups<br \/>\nwhere students can collect electronic resources, annotate and highlight<br \/>\nthese resources, and share all this information with others.<br \/>\nMoreover, students can collaboratively discuss electronic content on<br \/>\nthe margins of a digital paper and tie it back to a specific text section<br \/>\n(s). This information sharing could be done either synchronously (i.e.,<br \/>\ninstant sharing of information with others who are present\/available<br \/>\nonline) or asynchronously (i.e., sharing of information while others<br \/>\nare not available online). When information sharing is done asynchronously,<br \/>\nthe SA technology notifies about the changes made. Some SA<br \/>\ntools enable public notes sharing and text formatting.However, the majority<br \/>\nof the SA tools do not support the text-formatting feature yet.<br \/>\nThe first three SA features (i.e., annotations, highlights, and collaboration\/<br \/>\ninformation sharing online platform) described above, define<br \/>\nthe concept of SA educational technology, and are common among<br \/>\nall SA tools. What distinguishes one SA tool from another is its design<br \/>\nand technical features. Glover, Xu, and Hardaker (2007) provide<br \/>\na list of literature-supported requirements and desirable<br \/>\nconceptual and technical factors for SA educational systems (see<br \/>\nTable 1). These requirements have been drawn based on the examination<br \/>\nof the literature related to web annotation and assessment of publicly available systems. According to Glover et al. (2007), the list is<br \/>\nneither exhaustive nor absolute since differences exist among various<br \/>\nSA tools. Nevertheless, the listed requirements provide a generic overview<br \/>\nof the considerations that might be encountered when selecting<br \/>\na SA tool for education purposes.<br \/>\nMany annotation online tools have been developed over the last decade,<br \/>\nincluding Gibeo (Bateman, Farzan, Brusilovsky, &amp; McCalla, 2006),<br \/>\nAnnotea (Wu-Yuin, Chin-Yu, &amp; Mike, 2007), EDUCOSM (Nokelainen,<br \/>\nKurhila, Miettinen, Floreen, &amp; Tirri, 2003), Diigo (Kawase et al.,<br \/>\n2009), HyLighter (Lebow &amp; Lick, 2004), The Fluid Annotations projects<br \/>\n(Zellweger,Mangen, &amp; Newman, 2002), andMADCOW(Bottoni<br \/>\net al., 2004, 2006).<br \/>\nThe growing number of social annotation technologies can be<br \/>\nexplained by the need for using such tools in various settings and<br \/>\nthe benefits this technology offers. Collaborative annotating allows<br \/>\ncollecting and organizing of resources, and accessing and sharing<br \/>\nthem with others easily from anywhere. The collaborative aspect of<br \/>\nthese tools creates a sense of community among the users in a<br \/>\ngiven system and allows them to become more involved in the community<br \/>\n(Bateman et al., 2006). The SA tools are particularly useful for<br \/>\nteams working on projects.<br \/>\nSA tools have been successfully used in educational settings. Researchers<br \/>\nclaim that annotation technologies increase participation<br \/>\nand engagement (Lebow &amp; Lick, 2004; LeeTiernan &amp; Grudin, 2001, as<br \/>\ncited in Wu-Yuin et al., 2007), improve instruction (Lebow &amp; Lick,<br \/>\n2004), promote attention, communication, and organization (Yang et<br \/>\nal., 2004, as cited in Huang, et al., 2008; Davis &amp; Huttenlocher, 1995,<br \/>\nas cited in Wu-Yuin et al., 2007). Annotations can improve reading<br \/>\ncomprehension and peer-critique skills (Archibald, 2010; Johnson,<br \/>\nArchibald, &amp; Tenenbaum, 2010; Mendenhall &amp; Author, 2010). In addition<br \/>\nto benefiting the annotator, other readers may also benefit<br \/>\nfrom reviewing shared annotated documents (Kawase et al., 2009).<br \/>\nReaders may benefit by gaining ideas, seeing others&#8217; different perspectives,<br \/>\nand building knowledge about the annotated resource.<br \/>\nHowever, most of the mentioned benefits have not been supported<br \/>\nby a rigorous empirical research. There are many challenges inherent<br \/>\nto the use of SA technologies in educational settings (Johnson<br \/>\net al., 2010). It is unclear how to use these tools to improve academic<br \/>\nachievement. Do students really benefit from using SA tools? No<br \/>\ncomprehensive literature review investigating the SA use in educational<br \/>\nsettings and SA effect on academic achievement has been<br \/>\nfound.<br \/>\nThe purpose of the paper is to review existing literature related to<br \/>\nthe (1) uses of SA in educational settings and (2) effects of SA technology<br \/>\non learning. A literature review of empirical studies concerning<br \/>\nthe use and the effect of social annotation tools in higher educational<br \/>\nsettings is presented in this paper. The questions underlying this review are: (a) Does SA technology lead to any learning gains in higher education,<br \/>\nand under what conditions does SA promote learning? (b) What<br \/>\nare the general learning benefits and learning outcomes linked to SA?<br \/>\n(c) How has SA technology been embedded into instructional activities<br \/>\nandwhat types of learning have been facilitated themost through using<br \/>\nSA technology?<br \/>\n2. Method<br \/>\n2.1. Procedure<br \/>\nA large body of literature focusing on online social annotation<br \/>\ntools was gathered and reviewed. The following online databases<br \/>\nwere employed for the literature search: ERIC, PsychInfo, and ScienceDirect.<br \/>\nIn addition, Google Scholar was used to search for and acquire<br \/>\nspecific references.<br \/>\n2.2. Inclusion criteria<br \/>\nThe focus of the search was to gather full-text articles presenting<br \/>\nempirical studies employing social annotation tools in educational settings.<br \/>\nIn order tomake the number of the reviewed articlesmanageable<br \/>\nbut comprehensive, exhaustive review with selected citation approach<br \/>\n(Cooper, 1988)was implemented. Specifically, the studies were included<br \/>\nin the literature review if they met each of the following criteria:<br \/>\n1. The study employed an online SA tool that embodied at least the<br \/>\nfollowing three features: (a) annotations, (b) highlights, and<br \/>\n(c) information sharing\/collaboration online platform.<br \/>\n2. The study examined either (a) usability of SA technology in educational<br \/>\nsettings or (b) effects of SA technology on general learning<br \/>\nbenefits or learning outcomes.<br \/>\n3. The study focused on higher education audience. Studies that<br \/>\nemployed K-12 population were excluded.<br \/>\n4. The study reported research methods (i.e., participants, instructional<br \/>\ninterventions, instruments, research design, etc.) and results.<br \/>\nStudies that employed quantitative research method<br \/>\nreported statistical analysis methods and results.<br \/>\n5. The research presented in one study did not overlap research from<br \/>\nanother study.<br \/>\n6. The article was written in English.<br \/>\nThe search was conducted using various search terms and keywords<br \/>\nsuch as online collaboration tools, annotation tools, online team<br \/>\nlearning tools, learning outcomes, and achievement. Since the SA tools<br \/>\nare an emerging technology that has not yet been adopted widely,<br \/>\nthe search was not limited to a particular date range, research<br \/>\nmethods, specific learning outcomes, or publication type. From over<br \/>\n90 initially collected articles, eight experimental and quasi-experimental<br \/>\nstudies and eight evaluation\/survey studies met the inclusion<br \/>\ncriteria for this literature review.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>1. Introduction Educational technology plays an important role in developing and supporting instructional activities that promote learning and facilitate students&#8217; engagement in a learning process. Social annotation (SA) tools are an emerging educational technology that has been drawing more of educators&#8217; attention over the last several years. SA technology is an online social bookmarking tool &hellip; <a href=\"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/testing-hypothesis\/\" class=\"more-link\">Continue reading <span class=\"screen-reader-text\">Testing Hypothesis<\/span><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"parent":0,"menu_order":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","template":"","meta":{"footnotes":""},"class_list":["post-8","page","type-page","status-publish","hentry"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/8","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/page"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=8"}],"version-history":[{"count":3,"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/8\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":47,"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/8\/revisions\/47"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/mikecosgrave.com\/annotation\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=8"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}